Monday, December 11, 2023

Rube Goldberg Would Be Proud – The Well being Care Weblog



Larry Levitt and Drew Altman have an op-ed in JAMA Community with the can’t-argue-with-that identify Complexity in the USA Well being Care Gadget Is the Enemy of Get entry to and Affordability. It attracts on a June 2023 Kaiser Circle of relatives Basis survey about shopper reviews with their medical health insurance. Lengthy tales brief: even supposing – unusually – over 80% of insured adults price their medical health insurance as “excellent” or “very good,” maximum admit they’ve problem each figuring out and the usage of it. And the folk in honest or deficient well being, who possibly use well being care extra, have extra issues.

Medical health insurance is the objective on this case, and this is a honest goal, however I’d argue that it’s good to select virtually any a part of the healthcare device with equivalent effects. Our healthcare device is easiest instance of a Rube Goldberg device, which Merriam Webster defines as “conducting by way of advanced method what apparently might be carried out merely.”   

Boy hey.

Medical health insurance is many of us’s favourite villain, person who many would care to do with out (particularly medical doctors), however let’s now not forestall there. Healthcare is stuffed with 3rd events/intermediaries/middlemen, that have ended in the Rube Goldberg construction.

CMS doesn’t pay any Medicare claims itself; it hires 3rd events – Medicare Administrative Contactors (previously referred to as intermediaries and carriers). So do employers who’re self-insured (which is nearly all of non-public medical health insurance), hiring 3rd birthday celebration directors (who would possibly occasionally even be well being insurers) to do community control, claims cost, eligibility and billing, and different duties.

Even insurers or 3rd birthday celebration directors would possibly subcontract to different 3rd events for such things as supplier credentialing, usage assessment, or care control (in its many bureaucracy). Take, for instance, the universally reviled PBMs (pharmacy get advantages managers), who’ve carved out a large area of interest offering products and services between payors, pharmacies, and drug corporations whilst elevating expanding questions on their precise worth.

Doctor practices have lengthy outsourced billing products and services. Hospitals and medical doctors didn’t broaden their very own digital scientific information; they shriveled with corporations like Epic or Cerner. Well being care entities had hassle sharing information, so alongside got here H.I.E.s – well being knowledge exchanges – to assist transfer a few of that information (and HIEs are actually transitioning to QHINs – Certified Well being Knowledge Networks, because of TEFCA).

And now we’re seeing a veritable Cambrian explosion of virtual well being corporations, each and every considering it may possibly take some a part of the well being care device, put it on-line, and possibly make some a part of the healthcare enjoy rather less unhealthy. Or, seen from some other point of view, upload much more complexity to the Rube Goldberg device. 

On a contemporary THCB Gang podcast, we mentioned HIEs. I agreed that HIEs have been advanced for a excellent explanation why, and had carried out excellent paintings, however on this meant technology of interoperability they will have to be seeking to put themselves into bankruptcy. 

HIEs known a ache level and located a approach to make it rather less painful. To not repair it, simply to make it much less unhealthy. The healthcare device is replete with intermediaries that experience workarounds which enable our healthcare device to lumber alongside. However as soon as in position, they keep in position. Healthcare doesn’t do sunsetting neatly.

In contrast to a real Rube Goldberg device, even though, there’s no actual design for our healthcare device. It’s extra like evolution, the place there are not any taste issues, no potency objectives, simply credit score for survival. Positive, occasionally you get a cat thru evolution, however different instances you get a unadorned mole rat or a hagfish. Healthcare has much more hagfish than cats.

I’m inspired with the creativity of many of those workarounds, however I’m awfully bored with wanting them. I’m awfully bored with accepting that complexity is inherent in our healthcare device.

Complexity is unhealthy for sufferers, unhealthy for the folk without delay giving the care, and best excellent for all of the folks/entities who make a residing in healthcare as a result of if it. As an alternative of creating ache issues much less painful, we will have to be eliminating them.

If we had a magic wand, shall we remake our healthcare device into one thing a lot more practical, a lot more efficient, and far more cost effective. Sadly, we now not best don’t have any such magic wand, we don’t even agree on what that device will have to seem like. We’ve gotten so used to the advanced that we will be able to now not see the straightforward.

I don’t have a Utopian imaginative and prescient of a healthcare device that will resolve all of the issues of our device, however I do have some tips for all of the innovators in healthcare:

  • In case your resolution makes sufferers fill out another shape, log into another portal, make another telephone name, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution takes time with sufferers clear of clinicians, making them do different duties as an alternative, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution doesn’t create knowledge this is going to be shared to assist sufferers or clinicians, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution best specializes in a point-in-time, slightly than serving to an ongoing procedure, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution is designed to extend earnings slightly than to beef up well being, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution doesn’t acknowledge, recognize, file and act on screw ups/errors/mistakes, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution can’t merely be defined to a layman, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution provides to the healthcare device with out decreasing/getting rid of the desire for one thing even larger within the device, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution steers care to sure clinicians, in sure puts, slightly than in the hunt for the most productive maintain the affected person in the most productive position, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution provides prices to the healthcare device with out uniquely and particularly decreasing much more prices, please rethink.
  • In case your resolution doesn’t have integrated mechanisms (e.g., use of A.I.) to be and keep present on an ongoing foundation, please rethink.

 I’m positive all the ones innovators suppose their concept may be very suave, and lots of are, however take into account: simply because an concept is suave doesn’t imply it’s now not Rube Goldbergian.  They want to step again and consider in the event that they’re including to healthcare’s Rube Goldberg device or serving to simplify it. My wager is that most often they’re including to it.

So, yeah, I accept as true with Mr. Levitt and Dr. Altman that medical health insurance will have to be much less advanced.   Similar to the entirety else within the healthcare device. Let’s get started taking the healthcare Rube Goldberg device aside.

Kim is a former emarketing exec at a big Blues plan, editor of the past due & lamented, and now common THCB contributor.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Stories